Will holding wrongdoers liable actually change anything for nature?

By Jacob Phelps and Joana Setzer

We work in the field of legal accountability – researching and litigating strategic cases against parties responsible for causing egregious harm to nature. And although it is clear that wrongdoers should be held responsible, we are often asked “...but does liability litigation actually work? Can it change broader systems?” 

Strategic liability cases typically seek to hold responsible parties accountable for remedying the harm they cause – whether to human wellbeing, biodiversity, the climate system or waterways. This often means not only ordering wrongdoers to pay monetary compensation for the harm they cause, but imposing a higher bar that delivers remedies on-the-ground: demanding that mining corporations support actions to reforest the habitat they destroyed, that industrial polluters restore soils and waterways, and that wildlife traffickers ensure the care of the animals confiscated from them and support conservation actions.

Many colleagues ask whether this type of accountability can truly drive broader transformative changes in society.

There is evidence of transformative changes across contexts. For example, on public health issues such as smoking (Palin and Young 1994) and the opioid crisis (Haffajee 2020), high-profile liability litigation held corporations accountable for the harm they caused. Across contexts, liability cases have proved important not only to the individual victims – who have often secured clean-up, monetary compensation, access to healthcare, apologies and habitat restoration – but have also cumulatively driven broader changes:  across contexts, liability cases have added to a body of precedents, until the perceived costs of causing harm have created shifts (White and O’Callaghan-White, 2021; CLN, 2025). In this way, litigation can hit corporations' bottom lines (economic, reputational and moral) in ways that drive sector-wide changes, inform public policies and shape public opinion.

In the environment sector, litigation in many countries has typically been against government agencies, rather than against the corporations, individuals and organised criminal groups that also drive harm. However, in the USA decades of litigation based on the federal Clean Water Act have imposed liability on individual and corporate landholders that unlawfully discharge pollutants into water, including the obligation to remedy the harm this causes. Waves of liability litigation over toxic pollutants, such as cases against the corporations responsible for “forever chemical” pollution, are driving multi-billion dollar clean-ups and pay-outs that are shaping corporate behaviours;  perceptions of liability and reputational risks, including among insurers (Smyth 2023; Bugg and Caples 2025; Planet Tracker 2026), and are driving changes to government policy and standards – even beyond the jurisdictions in which the original litigation was brought (Bugg and Caples 2025).

Indeed, private law firms are increasingly warning corporate clients about the emerging risks of litigation – including about the risks of harming nature, and encouraging them to voluntarily strengthen their due diligence rather than face expensive litigation (e.g., Hamster 2022; Sedilekova and Lawrence 2022). This is compounded by growing evidence that litigation affects corporate earnings – including litigation over pollution (Planet tracker 2026) and climate change (Sato et al. 2024). We also know of anecdotal cases where litigation has limited responsible parties’ ability to secure bank loans. Most recently, an analysis of market responses to diverse nature litigation cases across Europe and North America found that decisions reduced corporate defendant's value by 1.8% (Dees et al. 2026). Notably, researchers found “evidence of sectoral spillover effects, where litigation against a single firm triggers negative contagion across the industry.” Following litigation, the broader sector also suffered 0.86% reduction in value, reflecting the cascading impacts of litigation on broader sectors.

The trajectory towards greater legal responsibility is clear. This polluter-pays legal trend is expanding to the fossil fuel sector (Setzer et al. 2026) and there is scope for these approaches to be applied even more broadly across high-risk sectors: to agricultural companies in the coffee, soy, cattle, sugar and palm oil sectors that are driving deforestation, wildlife trafficking syndicates that are commercialising the world’s most endangered species, and mining companies that are destroying habitat and polluting waters. Much of the academic debate on climate and pollution litigation gets stuck on issues of complex causation and who should receive remedies, especially given how diffuse and delayed these types of harm often are, and how far the harm travels from the corporations responsible for it. However, litigation over many other types of harm to nature do not face those problems – causal pathways to harm are often more linear (e.g., deforestation, wildlife trade), in which the recipients of remedies are the reforested habitat, the specific confiscated animal, the injured waterway. When the repair goes to nature that was harmed, that specificity can help these remedies become transformative in a way broader liability payouts aren’t.

Liability litigation is not a silver bullet for nature, but it doesn’t need to be one operating alone. The evidence suggests that litigation can shift the calculus that corporations, individuals and criminal networks use. It works alongside regulation, due diligence pressure, public campaigning and incentives –  not as a replacement for any of them. Isolating exactly how much of any sector-wide shift is attributable to a single case remains difficult (Barber, 2012). But the direction of the evidence is consistent, and accountability for providing remedies is a necessary strand in a wider shift.

Next
Next

Precedent-setting lawsuit seeks accountability and remedies for nature